Chomsky vs. Skinner: In Their Own Words
$15.00
In 1957, B.F. Skinner published the book Verbal Behavior. In 1959, a young linguist named Noam Chomsky published a review of that book that sharply criticized Skinner’s behaviorism in general and his behavioral approach to language acquisition in particular. Chomsky’s review became arguably more influential and well-known than Skinner’s book, and it played a key role in the “cognitive revolution” that soon came to dominate both psychology and linguistics.
The debate between the pragmatism of Skinner and the structuralism of Chomsky continues to this day. Now hear directly from both men, in a series of archival interviews and speeches spanning several decades, as they address the philosophical and practical differences between their approaches.
Description
In 1957, B.F. Skinner published the book Verbal Behavior. In 1959, a young linguist named Noam Chomsky published a review of that book that sharply criticized Skinner’s behaviorism in general and his behavioral approach to language acquisition in particular. Chomsky’s review became arguably more influential and well-known than Skinner’s book, and it played a key role in the “cognitive revolution” that soon came to dominate both psychology and linguistics.
The debate between the pragmatism of Skinner and the structuralism of Chomsky continues to this day. Now hear directly from both men, in a series of archival interviews and speeches spanning several decades, as they address the philosophical and practical differences between their approaches. Topics addressed include:
- Verbal behavior, linguistics, and language acquisition
- Structuralism
- Morality
- Nature vs. nurture
- Fascism and racism
- Rule-governed behavior
- Universal grammar
Based on a video originally edited and posted to YouTube by Ariel Raphaeli in 2012.
Free Preview
Below is the entire open access version of this video. It does not contain embedded questions or interactions like the CEU version of the module.
You may also like…
-
6 CEUs
An Introduction to Verbal Behavior
(295)$60.00 Add to cartquick view -
1.5 CEUs
Relational Frame Theory and Skinner’s Verbal Behavior: A Possible Synthesis
(15)$15.00 Add to cartquick view -
6 CEUs
An Introduction to Relational Frame Theory
(484)$60.00 Add to cartquick view -
1.5 CEUs
B.F. Skinner on Education
(18)$15.00 Add to cartquick view
Related products
-
1 CEU
Matter of Great Consequence: The Standard Celeration Chart
(3)$20.00 Add to cartquick view -
1 CEU
How Can We Increase the Impact of Behavior Analysis in Solving Problems in New Areas?
(6)$20.00 Add to cartquick view -
1.5 Total CEUs1.5 Ethics CEUs
Ethics of Punishment Panel Discussion
(22)$30.00 Add to cartquick view -
1 CEU
Autism from Age 2 to 26: What Can We Learn About Treatment from Longitudinal Studies
(5)$20.00 Add to cartquick view
I very much enjoyed this presentation. It was insightful to listen to both men explaining the rivalry between linguistics and behaviorism in greater detail and was a great review of these philosophies of language.
I enjoyed the videos and follow up questions. I did learn more about Skinners
and Chomskys perspectives. When I struggled to answer a question it was very difficult to figure out how to rewatch parts of the video. For the first few minutes I had the speed up high, making it difficult to follow and I struggled with slowing down the video. Once I figured out the controls it was a bit easier.
Interesting!
SO COOL! Great to go back to the origins and hear from the individuals who provided the science behind the origins of our field. Awesome to see Skinner had a sense of humor too! Thought this was going to put me to sleep but kept me on the edge of my seat instead!
Loved this! So fun with the original footage!